Book Review: “Trickster City” by Various Authors

On: September 21, 2010
Print Friendly
About Megan Adams
I have traded my life of Tex-Mex and warm weather in Austin, Texas (yes I was raised on a ranch and no, George Bush is technically from Connecticut) for the gezelling city of Amsterdam to pursue my MA in New Media from UvA. Since graduating in 2006 with a Bachelor degree in Communication from St. Edward's University, I have thrown myself into the fast paced life of PR working at various levels across the technology and consumer sectors. Why new media? My professional interest in the program lies in understanding how new mediums and tools influence the communication landscape and why. In turn I hope to directly apply this "under the hood" insight to my PR approach. My personal interest is vested in exploring the latest and greatest that the internet gods have bestowed upon us. When I’m not accidentally mowing over pedestrians on my bike I enjoy all things music and travel related. My idea of the perfect blog would combine the finer things in life: sandwiches and Lil Wayne.

Website
http://imonabike.wordpress.com    

India has long since been on my list of places I must visit before I die.  I’m fascinated by the unknown and India is definitely a country that is completely unknown to me.  Aside from cultural references in books, television, movies (Darjeeling Limited, I love you), etc., I can’t say that I have a real understanding of what life is like in a place that more than a billion people call “home.”

Trickster City is a part fictional, part documentary recount of daily life surrounded by 15 million people in Delhi, India as told from the perspective of a group of twenty somethings.  This candid look into life as told by the people who live it makes you inspect each story carefully, looking for clues of whether what you were reading were true or fiction; A testament to the writing is that you could not tell where that line was drawn.

A small group of 20 people came together to share their thoughts, ideas, personal triumphs, tragedies and intimate life experiences that make up Trickster City. This group of contributors are all members of Sarai’s Cybermohalla.  Cybermohalla literally means “cyber neighborhood” (mohalla is the hindi and urdu word for neighborhood) but the mission statement is much more personal:  “Sarai’s Cybermohalla project takes on the meaning of the word mohalla, its sense of alleys and corners, its sense of relatedness and concreteness, as a means for talking about one’s ‘place’ in the city, and in cyberspace.”

Knowing upfront that this book related to the Sarai lab I was expecting to have learned or read something about new media as it pertains to daily life in India.  Unfortunately there was no such trace of this in the book.  Instead the stories, fiction or not, painted the picture of a more bleak and disappointing life growing up in the “lanes” of Delhi.  The Commonwealth Games which are being held next month were actually the precursor to the demolition of an entire neighborhood where several of the contributors had grown up and lived in all of their lives.  This demolition was done in part to clean up Dubai, which is hosting the games.  However, the depiction of this devastation as told by the people who experienced it, bore an eerie resemblance to the horror stories of Nazi Germany where Jews were displaced from their homes at a moment’s notice, with nowhere else to go.

Released in February of this year, the book, a collection of short stories, was divided into sections: arrival, en route, repartee, whereabouts, eviction, incognito, encounter and frontier.  Obviously these sections were divided carefully for a reason.  Based on titles alone they portray the rhythm of something less permanent, of someone passing through.  As I’m sure they were intended, these sections provide a good framework for understanding the direction of the book, but only until you get more than half way through.

My main “technical” criticism of the book is that it’s a bit too presumptuous about its reader’s knowledge of cultural language in India.  While an easy read I still had to mentally flag quite a few phrases and words to look up so I could understand their context.  I understand that this was likely done in effort to preserve the authenticity of the stories but it often broke my stride in that I couldn’t quite move on from the word(s) that I didn’t understand.

Trickster City is an interesting book if you’re looking at Dubai or India for that matter, with fresh eyes.  I wouldn’t describe this book as particularly engaging afterall the stories are a guessing game between what’s real and what’s fiction, but it does pull back the curtains for a glimpse inside a sprawling metropolis.

Interested in checking it out for yourself?  This book is available for purchase here.

Contributors:

Azra Tabassum

Jaanu Nagar

Lakhmi Chand Kohli

Rakesh Khairalia

Yashoda Singh

Kiran Verma

Suraj Rai

Neelofar

Kuliwinder Kaur

Shamsher Ali

Babli Rai

Ankur Kamar

Dilip Kumar

Love Anand

Nasreen

Rabiya Quaraishy

Sunita Nishad

Saifuddin

Arish Quareshi

Tripan Kumar

Translated by Shveta Sarda

Leave a Reply