Facebook’s new virtual assistant ‘M’: mastermind or menace?

On: September 15, 2015
Print Friendly, PDF & Email
About Lianne Kersten


Facebook recently introduced the world to ‘M’, its brand new virtual assistant that will reside in Facebook’s messaging app. Will, because for now, the new application is still in its test phase. Nonetheless, this rather unexpected move of Facebook is interesting to say the least.

What makes M special?

In contrast to many other virtual assistants, M can actually complete tasks for you, like ordering flowers, making dinner reservations or calling customer service desks. How? Well, there are a couple of significant differences between M and its predecessors. The new application communicates solely via text and, more remarkably, is still co-dependent on humans. Facebook has taken a step back – or maybe one step back, two steps forward – in artificial intelligence and called in actual people to help on this one.

A team of trained Facebook-employees will work beside the algorithmic software to answer difficult questions or fulfill tasks like making a call. Meanwhile they train M, so in the long run it will learn to do things on its own – or at least that’s the goal. Every step the trainers make is documented. Cade Metz explains on WIRED: ‘This includes what websites they visit, what they say when calling, what they type in response to M users, and so on. In the future, this data can help drive a more advanced system based on deep learning. In doing that heavy-lifting, the humans generate a roadmap for how particular questions should be answered.’


A new and different approach to virtual assistance, that’s for sure. But why Facebook’s sudden interest in joining the gang of digital sidekicks? Next to Apple’s Siri, Microsoft’s Cortana, Google’s Google Now and Amazon’s Alexa (which all use, in contrast to M, mere voice recognition algorithms), isn’t the club getting rather crowded?

It’s nothing new that social media platforms such as Facebook are monetized through the vast sums of data they accumulate. Data which, as Cruz, Oboler and Welsh (2012, 3) point out, is avidly used by business clients, governments, other users within the social media platform and the platform provider itself. According to the authors, ‘accounts that are frequently updated and used across multiple aspects of a persons life offer the richest data, and possibly also the greatest risk’. No wonder Facebook wants to add to their data by moving into new fields.

Gaining ground in search

According to Cruz, Oboler and Welsh (2012, 4) in order for the information to go up in value, a primary key that connects the data with existing information is mandatory. And that’s where Facebook’s billions of user IDs come in handy. And besides this, consumers are using social media more and more frequently to look up information and make their purchase decisions (qtd. in Mangold and Faulds 2009, 5).

With M, Facebook has taken its first strategic step to permeate the lucrative realm of web search. Instead of typing your query into the ubiquitous search engine, you now put your request straight into your conversation with M who then does the searching for you. In an interview with WIRED, Marcus even declared it his main goal to make Messenger the first stop for mobile discovery – instead of Google Maps, Siri or even Twitter – subsequently changing the role Facebook has in our lives for good.

“If you are not paying for it, you are not the customer, you are the product being sold.” Andrew Lewis, blue_beetle. [1]

It goes without saying that Facebook is hoping to make M into a profitable extension of their services. How is pretty obvious: new integrated M-ads, making deals with companies in order for M to ‘keep them in mind’, and all in all just another trick on Facebook’s sleeve to keep you in their moneymaking sphere even longer.

But the Big Data M will collect is the real gold mine. A small plus: M won’t use the large chunks of data Facebook already has about us to help you, at least at first. It will only take information from previous conversations. Still, this could be worrisome. Smith and Szongott (2013, 1) warn us: ‘When data about us is collected and minded by companies such as Facebook, it becomes a sociological problem. Data applications lie in the new domains of the social web, consumer and business analytics and governmental surveillance. In which research is being used to create and analyse profiles of us.’ The more data you put in, the more data will be stored in your own personal file. Something to be careful of, especially given, as Smith and Szongott (2013, 3) frankly put it, ‘Facebook’s ever changing, complex and sometimes abstruse privacy settings.’

What is next? 

One single company that has access to your age, gender, pictures, public (and private) messages, exact location, background and consequently tracks everything you like. That same company is planning to start an additional database containing all of the things you search for, question, or even as much as consider doing. And it might even begin to predict what you will do in the future.

So the more you ask, the more M knows, the more Facebook becomes all-knowing. And it’s completely up to them what they’ll do with that.


[1] A quote that went viral in the debate around Big Data, first posted in August 2010 by Andrew Lewis (username: blue_beetle) on community weblog Metafilter.



Angwin, Julia. “It’s Complicated: Facebook’s History of Tracking You.” ProPublica. 17 June 2014. <http://www.propublica.org/article/its-complicated-facebooks-history-of-tracking-you>

Cruz, Lito, Andre Oboler and Kristopher Welsh. “The Danger of Big Data: Social Media as Computational Social Science.” First Monday. 17. 7 (2012). 13 June 2012. <http://firstmonday.org/ojs/index.php/fm/article/view/3993/3269>

Hempel, Jessi. “Facebook Launches M, Its Bold Answer to Siri and Cortana.” WIRED. 2015. 26 August 2015. <http://www.wired.com/2015/08/facebook-launches-m-new-kind-virtual-assistant/>

Mangold, Glynn and David Faulds. “Social Media: The New Hybrid Element of the Promotion Mix.” Business Horizons. 52. 4 (2009): 357-365.

Metz, Cade. “Facebook’s Human-Powered Assitant May Just Supercharge AI”. WIRED. 2015. 26 August 2015. <http://www.wired.com/2015/08/how-facebook-m-works/>

Metz, Cade. “Finally, Neural Networks that Actually Work.” WIRED. 2015. 21 April 2015. <http://www.wired.com/2015/04/jeff-dean/>

Smith, Matthew, Christian Szongott, Benjamin Henne and Gabriele van Voigt. Big Data Privacy Issues in Public Social Media. International Conference on Digital Ecosystems and Technologies, June 2012, Italy. IEEE: Leibniz University Hannover, 2013.

Comments are closed.